Ask HN: Would it be useful to have a slop button in addition to flag?

BugsJustFindMe

4 hours ago

5points

In these modern harrowing times, more and more posts are proving to be AI slop, and many people are averse to that. Do you think it would it be useful to have a way to indicate that you believe a post is slop separate from the existing flag button? Maybe it's just me but I feel like having a dedicated [AI slop] flag on a post would be useful because I feel differently about posts that have been flagged for other reasons than that. (or something friendlier if value is seen in the general idea but not in that language)

3 comments

Comments

jgrahamc•4 hours ago

Doesn't the flag button serve that purpose?

BugsJustFindMe•4 hours ago

I don't think it does exactly. I edited to clarify.

bell-cot•3 hours ago

From HN's FAQ:

> What does [flagged] mean?

> Users flagged the post as breaking the guidelines or otherwise not belonging on HN.

I'd favor having a second type of tag, for submissions, which meant "the linked article is of low quality". Doesn't matter to me whether it's AI slop, or press release puffery, or tedious drivel, or by a painfully unqualified author, or something else.

Yahyaaa•2 hours ago

[dead]